Issue Review – Dime Detective Magazine, Jan 15, 1935

This review of a detective pulp has been long pending. I wanted to review three issues of Dime Detective – one each from the 1930s, 1940s and 1950s to give a representative look at this great magazine.  To kick things off, let’s look at the January 15, 1935 issue. Dime Detective commenced publication in November 1931, and for the first few years, it looks like a weird menace magazine from the covers.

This issue is from what many collectors consider the peak period for Dime Detective (roughly 1934 to 1943). It’s squarely in the middle of the period when they were putting out two issues a month. This issue has stories by Erle Stanley Gardner and Norbert Davis, and appearances by series characters from Donald Barr Chidsey and Frederick C. Davis.

Dime Detective Magazine, January 15, 1935 cover by Walter M. Baumhofer

Dime Detective Magazine [v16 #1, January 15, 1935] (Popular Publications, Inc., 10¢, 128pp+, pulp, cover by Walter M. Baumhofer)

Interior illustrations by John Fleming Gould.

No letters from readers here, just a column from the editor talking about how even hard to believe stories are in fact based on real life, giving a couple of examples – one being a story in this issue, Tracks of the Turtle. Frederick C. Davis sent the editor a letter in which he quoted a Time article from 1931 December, describing the disease hereditary ectodermal dysplasia and saying that he based the character Alexander Alleyne on that article.

8 · Hard as Nails · Erle Stanley Gardner · nv; not the same as the story of the same name in the March 1925 issue of Black Mask 4/5

Dime Detective Jan 15, 1935 - Hard as Nails - Erle Stanley Gardner - Illustration by John Fleming Gould

Gilbert E. Best was as full of dynamic energy as a busy coffee percolator. He started out of the elevator before the door was more than half open, pounded his way down the flagged floor of the skyscraper hallway, not as a man who is in a frantic rush, but as one who is so filled with surplus energy that he finds an outlet in pounding the floor with his feet.

Excellent hard-boiled story by Gardner. Gilbert E. Best, a private investigator, is hired by a lawyer, Frank C. Dillon,  to find a key witness in the case of his client, Ellen Hanley, who was injured in an accident with a motor coach.  Walter Manning, the driver of the motor coach operated by the Airline Stageways Co., has been hidden away by the defense attorney, Sam Wigmore. Moreover, by pretending to offer a job, Wigmore has entrapped Ellen into signing a declaration of good health – a precondition for the job application.

Between the missing witness and this, the case against the Airline Stageways has collapsed. Both lawyers are unscrupulous, caring little for the injured party as long as their income isn’t threatened. Gil Best does his best for the client, using the crookedness of the defense attorney against him, and inducing Dillon to work for the benefit of the client with a combination of carrot and stick. To say more would be to spoil the story.

29 · The Gin Monkey · Norbert Davis · nv 3/5

Dime Detective Jan 15, 1935 - The Gin Monkey - Norbert Davis - Illustration by John Fleming Gould

An average story from Norbert Davis, nothing to complain about. A private detective is hired to find a drug-addicted sculptor. He finds him, rescues him from the clutches of a gang of crooks, takes the sculptor back to his flat. Later, as he revisits the sculptor’s flat, he is knocked unconscious and finds the sculptor murdered when he regains consciousness. Perhaps inspired by the Sherlock Holmes story The Adventure of the Six Napoleons. Davis is good at describing characters:

Minnie was twenty-six years old. She was small and nervous and quick-moving, and her brown hair had a way of straggling out from behind her ears. She was not what you would call beautiful if you had any regard for the truth. She wore large horn-rimmed glasses on the end of her short nose, and when she got mad she shook her fists and swore like a trooper and threw anything that happened to be handy that she could lift

….

Jake was a squatting mound of white in the shadows behind the short, high bar. He was sitting on a stool, leaning backward, with his bald, round head against the cash register. He had a handmade cigarette plastered in one corner of his mouth, and his mouth was open on that side, and air wooshed loudly in and out as he breathed.

52 · The Corpse Clue [McGarvey; Wainwright T. Morton] · Donald Barr Chidsey · nv 3.5/5

Dime Detective Jan 15, 1935 - The Corpse Clue - Donald Barr Chidsey - Illustration by John Fleming Gould

This was the third of nearly 30 stories about Morton and McGarvey from Chidsey. The first five appeared in Dime Detective and the rest of the series appeared in Munsey’s Detective Fiction Weekly and Argosy.

Morton, the older detective, is the brains, and McGarvey is the muscle. Both play their parts in this story of a Napoleon of crime, Edison J. Erskine, a master jewel thief who plans out his crimes ahead of time, uses an army of support staff, and always has a firm alibi for every crime. Erskine is in Miami, the home of Morton and McGarvey, clearly planning a major crime. But they have no clue who the target is, and the story is all about their attempts to find out and prevent the crime. Do they succeed? Read and find out…

A criminal, this Erskine? Why, a quieter, better behaved man would be hard to find! He sat gazing at the blue sea, at the creamy rollers, and he was almost blatantly inconspicuous on that beach where most of the bathers were trying to attract attention. He spoke to no one. Even the girl who sold lemonades from a basket-tray, and who clearly thought it part of her duty to keep unattached men from feeling lonesome, was not able to wring a smile from him. He bought a drink, and he nodded seriously, and paid her; but he seemed to give no attention to her talk.

…

For five days the schedule didn’t vary… If McGarvey had ever supposed that he would like to be one of the idle rich, he was well rid of that idea now. He thought nothing was ever going to happen again.

Morton, on the other hand, was expecting almost anything to happen. Clean and gray and somber, he sat in his office seventeen out of every twenty-four hours. He sent and received telegrams, made long distance calls, examined reports, shooed away newshawks. But most of the time he just sat there, staring at the ceiling, tapping his fingers upon the blotter, and wondering—wondering what he was missing.

76 · Tracks of the Turtle [Clay “Oke” Oakley; Secrets, Inc.] · Frederick C. Davis · nv 1.5/5

Dime Detective Jan 15, 1935 - Tracks of the Turtle - Frederick C. Davis - Illustration by John Fleming Gould

A weak story from Frederick C. Davis, with the most unbelievable part of the story being how the murderer arranged things to seem that the victims had been shot from one rifle rather than the other.

The Secrets Inc. series is being reprinted by Altus Press, and you can find other stories in this series in the collection The Complete Cases of Secrets, Inc., Volume 1.

110 · Murder as the Crow Flies · Oscar Schisgall · ss 3.5/5

Dime Detective Jan 15, 1935 - Murder as the Crow Flies - Oscar Schisgall - Illustration by John Fleming Gould

Three bank robbers kidnap a pilot and force him to fly his plane through bad weather at night to help them escape the pursuing police. The pilot is unarmed and outnumbered. He beats them, only to be arrested on landing safely. Worth reading.

120 · Bodyguard · Michael Kennedy · ss 2.5/5

Dime Detective Jan 15, 1935 - Bodyguard - Michael Kennedy - Illustration by John Fleming Gould

Another story by Chidsey, this one under a pseudonym. Six page story of a policeman trying to transport a witness safely to the USA from Europe, without losing the witness. Average story.

126 · Cross Roads of Crime: 8 · Richard Hoadley Tingley · pz

Cross Roads of Crime: 8 · Richard Hoadley Tingley

Crime crossword. My copy was blank, thought I’d put it in here for you to solve.

ACROSS	DOWN
1              The pictured man was a figure in the famous Dayton, Tenn„ case.	1              Hard substances
7              Dress	2              One who reviews and suggests
13           Trial	3              A hypothetical force
14           Slacken	4              Seat in a church
15           Chemical symbol for “lithium"	5              Auditory organs
16           Graphology	6              Slide
18           Opposite of “debit" (abbr.)	7              Dismounted
19           A suffix denoting an adherent	8              Mood
21           Malignance	9              An article of clothing
22           Murmuring note of a dove	10           Present tense of the verb “to be”
23           An antic or caper, not necessarily criminal	11           Jump back
25           Pictured man born here in 1857	12           To implant deep
26           Spume or spindrift	17           A variant of “si”
27           The spermatic organ of a male fish	20           Instruct
28           Chemical symbol for “cerium"	22           Place of residence of the pictured man
29           Abbreviation for “Established church”	24           Signs
30           Examine with the eye	25           The last
32           Hook used to handle fish	30           Expressionless
35           Makes lace	31           Our northern neighbor
36           Discount or rebate	33           Last scene
37           Single	34           Support; lend aid
38           Antithesis of capital	38           Mother of Appolo and Artemis
43           Opposite of “offs"	39           Again
44           The sixth musical note	40           Exist or live
45           Not specific	41           A city in European Russia
47           Near ; adjacent	42           A frog
48           To shape ideas	45           A fish with a saw-like snout
50           Empower	46           Tool of the pictured man
52           The pictured man's last name	49           A suffix used to form nouns of agency
53           The profession of the pictured man	51           Alongside